It may seem a rum do to use these BCB pages to promote another network, but the proposed closure of BBC’s digital station 6Music will be a great loss to new artists and music lovers alike, and anyone who enjoys Selection Box or indeed any of the other BCB specialist music shows should do everything in their power to show the BBC that any decision to close down 6Music should be reversed.
For further details as to how to join the campaign, go to http://www.love6music.com/ and sign the petition, join the Facebook group and also follow my example and complain to the BBC.
I have submitted my complaint to the BBC this evening. Here is my complaint in full:
Recent press reports have indicated that the BBC intends to close down its digital stations 6Music and the Asian Network. Having never listened to it, I cannot comment on the latter, so I shall confine my comments to discussion of 6Music alone, to which I am a daily listener.
Â
I think any moves to close down 6Music are unjustifiable and a betrayal of the corporation’s Missions & Values.
Â
In a press statement released today by BBC Director General Mark Thompson, he claims that the BBC “has the confidence to concentrate on what it does best: which is to deliver services of outstanding quality and originality and to be a beacon of creativity and excellence for audiences everywhereâ€. No other music station on the network demonstrates these values better than 6Music – a station which serves to bold enough in its approach to introduce new artists to a wider audience.
Â
This approach also has a knock-on effect to more populist stations such as Radios 1 & 2. The likes of Elbow, and Florence & The Machine – both regulars on the playlists of R1 & R2 – were first given regular airtime on 6Music and may have failed to reach the wider audiences without the play time from 6Music. 6Music is therefore aiding the breakthrough of artists as well as serving listeners with interest in artists from leftfield. To close down 6Music is therefore to stifle the creativity of the BBC’s other music radio stations.
Â
The initial report by the Times newspaper which claimed that the BBC was set to close 6Music claimed that “Mark Thompson, the Director-General, will admit that the corporation […] has become too large and must shrink to give its commercial rivals room to operate.” Any decision to close 6Music based on this proviso is entirely contrary. No commercial rival to 6Music exists – only Xfm attempts to cater to a similar audience, but it does not attempt the range or scope of 6Music, making its playlist of largely guitar-based acts, whereas 6Music seeks to reach all tastes and musical interests (within reason – classic music is left to the likes of Radio 3). No commercial station broadcasts a music show with a live act every night as Marc Riley’s 6Music show does. No commercial station broadcasts a mix of folk, jazz, soul, rock, punk, garage etc like the Freak Zone. No commercial station has shows dedicated to soul, heavy rock or dance. No commercial station is brave enough to take those risks. It is right and proper that the BBC is the corporation which has successfully taken the risks and pushed the boundaries as to what a music station can provide.
Â
The Times report also states that “only 20 per cent of adults knew that the station existed”. Not only is this actually a statistic of any true meaning or significance, it is also no excuse to dispense with the service. As Mark Thompson has said today in his statement, “in public space everyone is as important and as valuable as everyone else.” The public deserve to be served by the BBC we all pay for – and it is to the BBC’s credit that 6Music has been allowed to grow into the station it has now become since its inception in 2002.
Â
The results of a review of Radios 2 and 6Music was released last week. This was a review I personally contributed to via an online feedback form at the BBC website. The review states that “Over the last four years the station’s audience has grown faster than any other BBC digital radio-only
service”. This clearly shows that there is an audience for the service, and one where new listeners are sticking with 6Music as a station they wish to listen to.
Â
As I have intimated, the statistics given about the percentage of adults listening to 6Music are of little relevance to the debate and are effectively meaningless anyway. The claim that only 20% of adults in the UK have heard of the station actually equates to over 10 million people – more, I would argue, than a good deal of a lot of the BBC’s output. However, the success and importance of 6Music cannot be measured necessarily in volume. Listenership of stations like Radio 1 and Radio 2 is often habitual and made casually to a certain extent. It is flicked on in cars, at work places and at home often out of routine. In some of these places – particularly in cars – digital services are not available. Populist radio stations are often tuned into out of a search for something familiar, and listeners dip and out. Listeners to 6Music on the other hand are coming to the station out of purpose. They tune into the station because it offers something specific which is not available anywhere else.
Â
The BBC’s mission statement claims that “great things happen when we work together.” I implore the BBC to work with the thousands who have logged impassioned pleas in petitions and social networking sites to save 6Music from the chop. Great things have happened since the creation of the station, and its increasing listenership hope that even greater things will come in the future.
Â
Patrick Thornton presents Selection Box, Mondays at Midnight on BCB 106.6fm
You can also e-mail the BBC Trust with your concerns at trust.enquiries@bbc.co.uk. I believe I wide range of services are vital not only to the success of the BBC, but also services like BCB 106.6fm. The BBC leads the way in this country, and this filters through to other services. I dare say a lot of what is played on Selection Box may never have even reached my ears without airtime on 6Music and other BBC services. Even if I haven’t heard the artist directly on a BBC service, the liklihood is that they have been showcased by a 6Music show, or a similar artist has that has led me to try out someone new who has then led to another new act and another. It all filters down, basically. If we stop the source, the waters will run dry.
The BBC have now responded to my complain sent last night:
Thank you for your email in response to the strategic review of the BBC’s services. BBC Management have made the proposals to the BBC’s governing body, the BBC Trust. There is now a public consultation before any decisions are taken by the BBC Trust. It closes on May the 25th. To take part in the public consultation you can visit the BBC Trust’s website at bbc.co.uk/BBC Trust. Or you can write to the BBC Trust at 180 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5QZ. There is no need to enclose a stamped addressed envelope, or you can go online to bbc.co.uk/BBC Trust. To read the proposals in full please visit the BBC’s website at bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc. Thank you for contacting us and we hope you will take part in the public consultation.
Regards BBC Complaints
If its all over the press then i think its already to late. I will follow your actions though. It is contrary to what the BBC is about. No one else could afford to fund 6 music. But for the BBC its pocket change. BBC three costs 115 M a year to run. 6 Music 9 M … Now I am sure that there are many stats that the BBC has done regards cost per listner hour and thoughs figuares dont add up….but the BBC is not a purly commecial entity. Its there job to fund what others cannot for the public good right?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/mar/02/bbc-protests-change-mind-6music
Hummm, reason to protest.
Adam – it doesn’t look good, but the decision is still ultimately with the BBC Trust. The BBC Trust has already said that:
“If we find that there’s massive public concern that we need to take account of, then we will go back to the director general to rethink the strategy before it’s approved.”
I would therefore urge everyone with concerns to write to the Trust at both trust.enquiries@bbc.co.uk and the e-mail set up for the public consultation on the strategy review at srconsultation@bbc.co.uk and voice them. This not only goes for 6Music but also the Asian Network or indeed any other part of the review you have reservations or indeed agree with. I’ve always been of the view that there’s no point in complaining about things when you’ve failed to register your thoughts when given the opportunity.
You can also give your feedback on the review here: https://consultations.external.bbc.co.uk/departments/bbc/bbc-strategy-review/consultation/consult_view though be warned that the site keeps crashing – hopefully due to volume at 6Music listeners demanding the station be kept open.
For further updates go to http://www.love6music.com/, or just ask me because I’ll still be ranting about it, no doubt.
Pingback: When Selection Box met Kate Walsh / In BBC Trust We Trust | BCB Radios Music Blog - Untitled Noise
Pingback: When Selection Box met Kate Walsh / In BBC Trust We Trust « The Taking of Pelham Road